Navigating AI Integration in Independent Schools
Presented by:
The quarterly AI meetup, sponsored by Toddle, focused on the evolving landscape of AI in independent schools. Discussions covered the practicalities of integrating AI tools into educational settings, including challenges with teacher adoption of AI grading features and the need for comprehensive onboarding programs for both new and existing faculty. Participants also explored the implications of new tools like Google's Gemini and NotebookLM for student use, emphasizing the importance of digital literacy and parental education on AI's pervasive presence in school systems. The conversation highlighted the ongoing work in vetting new technologies for safety and effectiveness, and strategizing for future AI integration through dedicated school committees
- Toddle: https://www.toddleapp.com/
- Google Vids: https://workspace.google.com/vids/
- AI Literacy Framework: https://www.teachai.org/framework-for-teaching-ai (This is a widely recognized framework from TeachAI).
- Starting Smart with AI: A Quick Guide for School and System Leaders (The Learning Accelerator): https://learningaccelerator.org/resources/starting-smart-with-ai
- Profile of an AI-Ready Graduate (Richard Culatta on LinkedIn): https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/profile-ai-ready-graduate-richard-culatta-mwejc/
Transcript
Hey, everybody.
Welcome. Happy July.
I can't believe we're already like halfway through
July, by the way.
Um, I, I need like another six months of summer.
I don't know about y'all, but, um, I am not,
not ready for it to be July yet.
But, um, thank you for being on today.
This is an interactive session.
We do anticipate kind of a smaller group, uh,
with it being summertime and a lot going on.
Uh, but we're gathered here today
and we're gonna talk about ai.
And if you have any kind of burning questions
or things you wanna talk about or ask, uh,
we definitely welcome that as well.
Um, these meetups,
the whole meetup series is sponsored by Tattle.
So I wanna just let Cindy say hello to you guys.
So, Cindy, you wanna tell everybody? Hi. And how's it going?
Hi, Atlas. Um, it's, it's been so fun to be part
of this series and to learn alongside you.
I was lucky enough to be one of the moderators.
Um, and just to let you know,
if you checked out Title AI a while ago,
we've made quite a few changes in the last few months,
especially in the, the grading area and assessments.
Um, and I'm also working on an AI literacy course
that's gonna be like for teachers
and students to do together and have thinking organizers.
So keep an eye out for that.
Um, if you ever have questions about AI
or how TA can support you, feel free to reach out
to me on LinkedIn or at email.
I'll drop it in the chat. And
yeah, thanks for having me here.
Awesome. Thanks Cindy.
Thanks for joining us, and again,
for TA just sponsoring this entire, uh, series.
And so y'all, today we have a fantastic,
uh, facilitators.
So we have Jennifer, Jennifer is the director of
of technology at the Mount Vernon School in Atlanta,
Georgia, uh, which is an amazing school.
They're doing really innovative things there,
and they have a whole, like, innovation arm.
Um, and like a Jennifer, tell us a little bit about, uh,
first of all, you and your school
and then, uh, help us out today in just
guiding us through these questions.
Welcome. We're so glad, uh, you're here with us.
Thanks for having me. I appreciate it.
It's, uh, uh, it's a little difficult to, um,
to get back into the mindset I was, uh, painting earlier,
my painting my house earlier today
because I'm off, uh, today, so I'm gonna, I'm trying
to be intelligent for the rest of the call.
Um, but the, yeah,
Mount Vernon is an incredible organization.
We, um, it's wonderful to work here.
I have a great group of colleagues.
I'm sure you guys know many of them.
Um, and so we, we do try to, um, we joke
that we're not on the cutting edge sometimes.
We're on the bleeding edge, um, of technology.
Uh, and we do love to learn from each other.
So today isn't, um, I'm, I'm excited to be with you guys
and learn what you're doing and what you're thinking about,
especially as we are wrapping up summer unbelievably
and starting another school year.
Um, this will be my 27th in education,
so don't thank you for the filters.
Um, zoom, appreciate the filters.
Um, so we, you know, I just excited to be here, excited
to chat with you guys and see what you're up to and, uh,
and look forward to the next school year.
So, would you like me to take it over?
Yeah, that sounds great.
Um, so I have all kinds of things like questions.
I've got some very simple questions to get us going.
I also have some, uh, deeper provocations
to get us thinking about some things.
So maybe let's start light and see how we feel.
And, uh, if we're all in the mood for something heavier,
we can go a little bit deeper.
But, um, one of the, the fun things
that we've been doing is, um, sharing all the new tools.
I've been actually interviewing for EdTech positions.
And one of our questions is, what do you,
what have you just discovered recently
that you're intrigued by?
Or, um, what new tool or, or what concept
or what expansion of something that you're already working
with have you discovered recently or been working with?
So anybody wanna to share what they're playing
with in the world of technology right now?
Be brave.
I tried to play with the video makers to,
with very little success.
Um, I try to use just the Sora version,
not the, the expensive one.
And I just find the videos to be really awkward
and I'm seeing things that others are creating.
And I'm wondering if you have to have like an editorial
or like director lens to be better,
anybody thriving with the video making?
I keep wondering if I need like, lights
and certain cameras, and what do I need to make it look
as good as it looks for other people?
'cause I don't, it doesn't, it never looks that good for me.
I'm sure it's me. Anybody else working
with something cool that they wanna share?
It's only been playing around with, um, Google Vids.
Um, that's interesting.
It's something that I think was recently, um,
kind of made open for everybody.
Um, and that's, it's very intuitive, very quick
to pick up on, and, and, um, myself
and a colleague of mine were playing around with it
because it's essentially like a Google doc where you can,
um, live, edit anything you want to, um,
and you can have multiple people collaborating.
So it's, I can see implications for that in the classroom,
um, for any teacher that wants
to have collaborative video editing.
Um, but it, I think it could also go crazy really fast
with like middle schoolers.
Um, so I've been kind of dabbling with
that a little bit just to get some knowledge there.
Um, as well as, um, some of the AI tools in Canva.
Um, so that's, I haven't done a lot with that yet,
but that sounds like it's very promising.
That sounds great. Um, yeah, I wonder about tools
with in the hands of middle schoolers all the time,
what should we give them access to
and what should we maybe hold back a little bit?
Absolutely. It's a dangerous world.
Anybody else?
I hear you. Uh,
using existing tools in deeper and more meaningful ways.
Um, that's one of the things that we've been trying
to focus on too, essentializing, the tools that we're using
and making sure that we're using them to the maximum, uh,
before we go out and look for something shiny
and new, even though we all have a tendency to, to be very,
be very squirrel like.
Um, I'm super curious.
One of the things that we're struggling
with at my school is creating, um, creating an onboarding
that makes sense, especially
during pre-planning when it's already, uh, packed and full,
but creating an onboarding around AI for our teachers.
Uh, so I'm super curious.
Does anyone else have maybe a plan
or, you know, a way
that you're looking at onboarding teachers new to the school
and maybe some that have been around, uh, in terms of ai?
Is there anybody working on anything like that?
No, We're by ourselves
Actually. Uh,
most of our administrative team is away, um,
at this particular point in time,
but I do have meetings scheduled the last week of July to
plan for our touch points.
So we, we will be doing some within our,
with our new faculty who arrive on campus on August 5th,
and then our existing faculty.
But it's really more in the planning stages
and I high idea rather than specific
Anyone else? Yeah, same with
us. I've added it as a bullet point
to new faculty training,
but, um, haven't quite developed it yet.
So
Is that the idea mainly for most of you guys, is just
to find a place to kind of put it into the pre-planning,
onboarding, uh, sort of blend it in instead
of it being separate and pulled out?
Yeah. Uh,
Cindy's got a great question.
Anyone working with, uh,
the new European commission code.org curriculum,
Did you all get the notification about, um,
turning on Gemini and Notebook LM for your schools?
Yeah. Yeah. So let's talk about that a
Little bit. I imagine the decision is
a little bit different
for high schools than it is for, um, K to eight schools.
Yeah. Just to make sure everybody's, uh, tracking that,
and especially maybe if you're not a Google School.
So, um, Google basically, pretty much at in line
with Isti this year announced that they,
they now have their Gemini product open for all ages.
They've turned off the age restrictions.
They've been working on making the model a little bit more
appropriate, um, for the youngers youngers, the,
the little, the younger kids.
Um, so yeah. Where, where did y'all land with that?
For the schools that are Google?
Are you allowing and enabling student use for that, or No,
That's part of those late July conversations for us.
No, we, no, Cindy, we're not shooting it and pushing it off?
No, we actually met to set the dates in June,
um, when the announcement came out.
But again, everybody was ramping up
because July is vacation month, typically.
And so therefore we knew that we would be wrestling with
that and trying to determine what our stance was gonna be.
And everyone deserves a break.
I was totally kidding. Mm-hmm.
I understand that. We're just not
putting it down the road.
Yeah, we're a Google school as well,
and, um, we had been having, uh, a lot of requests
for Notebook, um, to be, you know,
and we kept having to express that it was, you know,
there were some age requirements, uh,
and some restrictions around it.
So I think a lot of our middle school teachers are excited.
Um, but I, we too haven't sat down
and really discussed what that might look like
for our middle school students, um,
because there, there do need
to be some parameters in our mind, um, for safety
and to, to ensure that we can, uh,
support the proper use of the tool.
But, um, I think the teachers are incredibly excited
that this might be a tool that they could use.
Yeah, we've had, uh, Gemini
and Notebook turned on for teachers.
Our big conversation is which students, when and why, right?
Because we invested in with Flint.
Part of that is teacher comfort to be able to see
what the prompt is, is from the student
with those Google tools.
You lose that visibility.
That's Right. And so that's part
of the bigger conversation
For us. It's likely gonna
be, um, uh, Gemini available for eight
to 12, um, from the very beginning.
And then we're gonna review with Notebook.
Lm I think it's very interesting that, uh, with, um, Gemini
as well, the integration into Google Classroom as well.
That's what we are, that's
what we're using at the moment as well.
So it'd be interesting to see just how well
that's gonna be integrated, um, together.
Absolutely. Um,
so I wanna bring up something that I,
I'm gonna shift my screen a little bit here.
So, um, I was on LinkedIn the other day,
and this post came up from a professor of economics
and he was talking about generative ai, uh,
and its use with students.
And he made a reference to, um, 12 Angry Men,
which I was a former high school English teacher.
So of course, I love it when folks make literary
references super exciting.
Um, and he was talking about that.
This story, of course, if you don't know it, is, um,
there's a teenage boy accused of murder,
and the jury of 12 men have to decide his fate.
Um, and right from the beginning, everyone is ready
to convict except for one man, juror number eight, uh,
who believes that more conversation is needed, um,
around this, uh, for this young man.
And so, one of the things that, uh,
was wonderful about this post is he was connecting
or comparing, uh, juror number eight, the voice sort of,
of dissension to what generative AI could be
for our students, thinking about, uh, generative AI
as something that could be, uh, a source of disruption
or friction or inte inte, uh, intellectual resistance.
Um, a way for kiddos to slow down their thinking instead of
speed up their thinking, their thinking.
Um, and so I'm super curious if anyone else is, uh,
looking at tools
or if you're looking at maybe, um, an approach,
I won't say policy, but maybe a position around
how your teachers are using AI in the classroom.
And if you're monitoring that or, or,
or maybe what you're, what you're doing to ensure that, um,
you know, students have this sort of approach, um,
or have multiple approaches in their tool belt,
if you, if you will.
I'm the curriculum nerd in the room.
So the, the literacy framework, I'm just gonna drop it here.
They outline seven skills,
and I think that's a cool framework
that I haven't seen elsewhere.
It's like the seven skills of working with AI is creativity,
computational thinking, whatever.
And I just think it'd be really cool for teams
to start thinking of that as a toolkit.
And almost like we map, um, like SDGs
or different things to assignments.
If we could map one of these AI skills
to summative assessments, I think could be a cool way
that we start doing it less piecemeal, less random,
and more documented.
We, um, we were also looking at changing our LMS, um,
we've been doing that over the summer, changing our LMSs
for two of them for grade six through eight,
and then one for nine through 12.
And in doing so, you have to sort of take your standards
and of course, kind of create, put them in their CSV files
to be uploaded into these new systems.
And what it's done is it's forced us to really kind
of look at what do we think about digital literacy
that is different now in this moment than it was when we
first started putting our standards in our systems.
And we have this great opportunity, um, I,
I'm looking at me be positive about this, uh,
this great opportunity to kind of revamp, revamp,
and rethink about how we want di Digital Literacy
to be part of the standards and where they fit best, um,
and how we can help support teachers in intentionally
assessing for those particular skills.
Um, and it's interesting
because we have always had digital literacy skills embedded
within the standards, but AI changes the nature.
Um, and so it's an, it's an interesting thing
that we're working on right now.
I'm gonna also drop in another resource. This was shared.
Uh, it's from the learning accelerator
and uh, it was shared in our AI summer workshop,
but, um, just something else to take home.
Very cool. Thank you.
Um, I'm super curious, are other folks trying
to incorporate AI into their strategic plan,
or is it just simply a part of what you're already doing?
Are you adding components of it into the strategic plan?
Are you talking, uh, about using AI
to build the strategic plan,
or are you talking about the fact that you are incorporating
and including elements of that within the strategic plan?
Um, I was going for question number two,
but I really like question number one better.
So are you guys using AI for something so, so beautiful
as building your strategic plan?
We start our planning process in September.
I'm on the committee, and we've gotten some background
materials that I'm in the midst of building a notebook LM
for people to explore those concepts.
That's very cool. That's neat, Benny.
That is really cool.
Oh, I love that emergence.
Uh, so Stacy's saying
that they created an emergency technology
statement last year.
That's a, that's an a mouthful. And
Emerging technology, not emergency,
but it's emerging technology. Sorry.
I was like, wow. Emergency, It's not emerging.
Yeah, it felt like an emergency.
AI is AI's in there, you know,
because we don't know where it's gonna go.
So we didn't wanna use ai,
we wanted to use emerging technology.
So yeah,
I think that, um, that's some of the things
that we're working on too, is shifting away from policies
and more about positions because policies feel so,
so stringent, right?
And so unchangeable, um,
and technology said so changeable right now.
Um, one of the things I love
that you put like a tech portrait of a graduate, um,
do you already have that flushed out?
Do you, are teachers using that?
So we, I just submitted it for approval.
Um, it's in pretty good shape.
The, the, the sticking point right now is the title
of all things, which is crazy.
Um, because we, we really like to use digital literacy
and not technology and people,
but people are feeling like portrait of a digitally literate
graduate feels condescending.
And so we're like, all right, do we go back to tech?
Like, what do we do? So we're stuck on that right now.
And so I'm trying to drive that forward,
but if you have any ideas for
what we should call this document, I'd love it.
We, uh, we have a portrait of a graduate
for the entire school, but then each department has their
own portrait of a graduate,
and that's what we map our, our Atlas Rubicon to instead
of like state standards
because we're independent school, so
we don't have to do state standards.
So we've created our own.
That's wonderful. Um, Cindy
and I did a really cool, um, activity with the D school
around, and, you know, there's the portrait of a graduate
and we've all sort of participated in that and we loved it,
but this was, um, it was portrait of an ancestor.
And so what it did was it made you really think about the
nature of education in this moment versus the education
nature of education for let's say, your great-grandchild
or, um,
and so what would we, what could we do now in education
to be preparing for that portrait of an nces, right?
So, um, it's a really cool idea to be thinking about, um,
you know, what do they need right now,
but then what do they need three years,
five years, 10 years down the road?
And what does that mean for us, um, in terms
of our planning and preparation?
And, uh, I don't think that any of us have a golden answer
for that, but we're all working very,
very diligently toward that.
So, but I think that's cool.
Really Long title. Go
for the really long title and just, you know,
So I dropped a link in the chat.
It is very specific to ai.
So if you're looking for something broader, again,
this is not gonna be your silver bullet,
but maybe some inspiration, um,
as you're considering different approaches.
And so this one was by Richard Colla.
Richard is the, believe his title is like CEO
and President of Isti and, uh, A SCD.
And, um, anyway, they created,
or he worked on the profile of an AI ready graduate.
Um, so that's an interesting one to just take a look at
and to consider as you're looking at skills
for emerging technologies.
I think you're gonna find a lot of alignment there.
He talks about, uh, really the students being synthesizers
and, uh, where they can I, uh, go through
and connect and, um, storytelling.
There's lots of different great
things in there, so check that one out.
That's very cool.
So one of the things that we're, um,
we are also working on at Mount Vernon is, um,
we have a consulting side of our school.
Um, so we have of course the day school
and we have our online school, um,
and then we have our consulting arm
and we live all, all sorts of versions of that.
And one of the things that we've been struggling with is
creating experiences for the online students
that will support the work that the,
the day school students do.
So that there's this sort of seamless movement.
So let's just say a kid, um, was taking classes
and then wanted to be able to, uh, double up maybe on math
and take a match class online at the same time.
And so trying to keep those experiences in line.
And so I was just curious if anybody else is doing anything
with online, online school, and if so, how technology
or ai either one of those is helping to support that work.
Um, I'd love some, you know, just
to hear what other folks are doing.
If, if you're doing online, um, support with your students.
Jennifer, do you know, uh, LDA Blood Flow?
The name is familiar, but I'm can't see a face in my mind.
She works, uh, so at, at her school they have like a brick
and mortar, but she's in charge of like the online arm.
And so I'd be happy to connect you guys if you're
interested in just learning more.
She's reached a grad of the A LI program
and is doing some really cool stuff. That'd
Be awesome. Yeah. Thank
you.
Um, okay, next question. 'cause we're also quiet today.
It's okay. It's summertime.
You don't have to be, you don't have to be on.
Um, and another piece that we're, we're contemplating is,
um, we do a lot of parent universities to help with
our parents learning how to use our systems
or how to learn, uh, more about, you know, whatever it is
that they're, that we feel is
important at that particular time.
And so we're, um, we're curious about maybe some
of the best ways that we could do some parent
education around ai.
Um, and, and maybe not just ai,
but how AI is a part of the systems that we currently use.
Um, for instance, um, we use tottle
and they're the AI tutors within tottle.
Um, there's the AI grading that,
uh, Cindy mentioned earlier.
Uh, and so it'd be really, I'm really curious, like,
are you guys doing intentional te parent training
around technology, specifically ai?
And if so, how does that look for your school?
Are you doing it, uh, you know,
as information that goes home?
Are you inviting them on campus?
What does that look like for you guys?
We did a parent forum last year, um, and,
and in the DMV, there was a showing of the, the name
of the movie's escaping me,
but the, it was an AI movie that came out last year.
Um, it'll come to me anyway, they did a, a showing of that
and our PTA
or whatever we call that here, um, I can't remember.
Um, sorry, my brain is really fried today.
I've been doing policy documents for like the past two days
and I can't see straight.
But anyway, um, so I did a, a parent form around that.
I had two of them actually, where parents were able
to come in and ask questions
and we were able to talk about like what,
what things they were curious
about and what they wanted to learn.
And so my hope is then that this year we'll work
with our parents association to then do some, um,
either asynchronous classes, which I haven't quite worked
through that yet, or just some online forums for them
to join and, and to ask questions for me
to show them how to do a few things.
Because we have a really wide range of tech executives
who are actually working in AI to people who are,
oh, this is really scary.
I don't ever wanna touch it. So
In your forms, are they led by you
or are they led by somebody else in the school?
What does that look like? They're
Led by me, but it's sponsored by our parent association.
So it's president of the PTA who reached out to me,
and she starts it as a PTA meeting,
and then I come in and do the form.
Everything is online because we're a boarding school,
so we're international.
Um, and so people need to be able
to join from all over the world, so it's all online.
That's awesome. Any,
oh, that's a really great idea.
Showcases of student, student and teacher work.
Like, ha have you done that before?
A showcase of teachers, teacher work to parents? Vinny?
We have, uh, a little bit not in, in other areas,
not necessarily ai.
And so we, this year we are launching our
center for stem, which is the third
of our three new centers, uh, the first being the Center
for Leadership, entrepreneurship
and Finance, um, as well as, uh, wellbeing
and success is the second.
And so we're cross
doing some cross programming with them as well as just STEM
and AI only, uh, within that particular context.
And so do the, do the students
and teachers present live
to the parents or how does that work?
That's correct. We've done that in
through a science symposium that we've done, um, each
of the last, what, four year, three years.
Um, with a little bit of the AI work.
We're just putting some more formality
and tying it together with these new areas
that we have identified and been putting together.
That's really awesome. Love that.
Me too. I'm, I'm thinking how that could look.
Uh, you know, I'm thinking, I, I was an IB teacher for years
and I love the showcases and, uh, of learning.
And so I'm thinking, wow, how could we really showcase
what our teachers are doing for parents so
that they could see just how incredible
and how much work they are are putting into this thought
into the thought of AI and technology.
That's really awesome. I would love to see it.
Um, and, and then steal your ideas after that.
Yeah, that's interesting.
I wonder if we could have some kind of like showcase,
like we do some of this during the AI workshop,
but it would be cool if we had just like a informal,
basically what Vinny was just talking about,
but like for other schools.
Yeah, that's a great idea.
That's really cool.
Um, I don't know if anyone else is, is having a little bit
of, um, angst around this,
but as the tools are coming in, we're having a bit
of a hard time, uh, managing the requests for new tools,
vetting these new tools, um, curating these resources, uh,
in a way that is effective for teachers
and transparent for teachers.
You know, we get, can I have this, can I have that,
can we use this here or that?
And, um, it, it seems to be growing.
Last year was manageable, this year's already started.
And so I'm just curious if anyone else is looking to, um,
how you're curating your resources for teachers,
or if you are, or if you're, um,
do you have a team that helps you vet?
What does that look like for your school when teachers are,
are just constantly asking for, Hey, can we have this?
Or, Hey, can we have that? What
does that look like for you guys?
I just had, go for it. No, sorry. It's okay.
Uh, pony Frontier was on my podcast.
Have you guys read his book or seen his book?
Such a cool guy. Um,
and he shared his framework
that he like outlined for doing that.
And he says it's like three steps, fidelity, transparency,
explainability, and
that whoever the stakeholder is who's requesting the tool.
So like Fidelity, how, how well does this align
to our school, this value to our curriculum,
to those things.
Transparency, like what's the chain of command?
Where's the human in the loop?
And then explainability that you can
like justify the AI's output.
And I thought that was just really cool language
that you could use with families, with teachers, like,
I don't know, across the board to kind of
give transparency to that process.
I, I like that the, the explainability, right?
Anybody can, as long
as we can tell them the why they're usually on board,
even if they don't agree.
Um, but I, I'm super curious about this because,
and I'm, I'm struggling with, um, just the volume right now.
I think it, it is just, there's so much coming in.
Um, and,
and again, you know, everyone's looking at the shiny new
tools and they want to try that,
but hey, there's a membership for this one,
or this one's free for 30 days.
And, um, and so managing all of
that without stifling anyone's creativity and,
and honoring their autonomy, um,
but still vetting these sources
and making sure that, you know, there's a level
of data privacy and security around them, um,
that we can live with.
And do we have redundant systems?
It's very interesting right now, um,
yeah, to be able to do that,
That, that's similar kind of thing with us as well.
So, um, we, uh, at our school we created,
it is just a Google form that, uh, teachers
or the head of the, the, the department would fill outs
and then, um, myself as the director at it
and the ed tech director will look at the request
and, um, just see what, uh, what's required, uh, at first,
and whether it's the cost
or data privacy, security, uh,
if we already have something in place that's very similar,
um, the ed tech director will, uh,
usually will look at it from, um, the perspective of, uh,
you know, the education rationale behind, uh, the request
and whether or not it makes sense to use
that in the classroom, um, the amount
of professional development that's required to, um,
to use it as well.
Uh, and then,
and then from there, we'll, we'll come together
and make a decision on whether or not to pursue it.
But I do agree with the fact that there are a lot of, um,
a lot of requests that come in, especially the beginning
of the school year, uh,
and especially from, um, uh, faculty members
who may have used a specific, uh,
software tool at a previous school
and they want to use it here as well.
Um, so we kind of are we, we, we do, I, for me,
like I do find that I need to pump the brakes
and a little bit for the people.
I kind of temper their, um, you know,
their enthusiasm a little bit,
but also making sure that they feel supported in a way
where, uh, we're not trying to stifle their, their, um,
their enthusiasm in any way,
but we kind of need to look at it from a perspective,
where does it meet all these, uh, requirements as well?
So for me, I would look at it from a perspective
where does it also align with this, um,
the school's privacy statement as well.
Um, and that kind of provides, for me, that kind
of provides a little bit more grounding on whether
or not we can pursue it from, um, the provi, uh,
for data privacy and security perspective.
And do you guys have like a, a way that you share
that information back out to your
Property? Yeah, right now
it's very little small,
so we just have it on a Google sheet
that we share on Vera Cross, uh, to the, to the faculty.
Um, uh, but I'm looking at tools to provide that as well.
I know there's tools online that do a lot of
that vetting process for you, uh, already.
Um, we haven't invested in that just yet,
but it might be something that we might need
to do if there are more and more requests that come in.
Yeah, so you need software too, huh?
Yeah, Maybe
Software to kind of help with the software, manage
Your software. Yeah,
Gerald, I love that.
So you've got, you know, the data privacy thing,
but also I think reminding people of the parent
and student experience.
You know, we had worked at a school where we had a set
of twins, and so they were in different classes
and all of their stuff was on different systems.
Like it was ridiculous for the parents.
They're like, wait, your homework is over here,
but you need to go over.
Like, it was so overwhelming for them to be able to even
navigate all of the different systems.
So kind of remind gently reminding people of, of
that Mike can help get 'em on your side a little bit.
Mm-hmm. Um, it's been really interesting
because I've heard more, I put this in the chat,
but I've heard more rumblings of consolidation
and people looking as the suite of tools
and all your new things that you have as they continue
to roll out more features,
people are actually looking at scaling back this year is
kind of a trend that I've been hearing
and picking up on from some of these conversations,
like these, um, an example
that I thought was interesting in an approach specific
to ai, uh, from the Mary Institute and St.
Louis Country Day School,
they are doing a bifurcated approach
that I think is just brilliant, where basically
they have a rollout
of like one standardized AI tool for their faculty.
And it was a, a more, uh, accessible tool that was easier
to learn, easier to use.
So like everybody got that tool.
And then for their select power users because of cost
and just again, feasibility here, they upgraded them
to a more of a frontier level model.
But again, it was only like this really
small handful of people.
But I thought that that was a fascinating way to like,
let your people that are, you know,
really far ahead have access to powerful models.
Um, but then let the others go and, and, and run with it.
But it's been fascinating too of all
of these different AI tools
that are now working off of the frontier models.
You may have connectivity and built into some really,
really powerful things as well.
So definitely worth examining.
I agree. We, um, one of the components, like I said,
we had to emergency uh, com, you know, it was a, we were
sunsetted with 30 days notice from our current LMS to,
and so for the last, uh, couple
of months we've been working on moving to a new LMS
and one of the things that we were considering was,
you know, when we are purchasing this very important piece
of software for our faculty, does it do more than one thing?
And so one of the components that was a requirement,
a non-negotiable for us, was having that built in ai, right?
I don't wanna have to have this tool
and then purchase another tool to do something else.
And so now we don't even really consider tools
unless, um, they are serving more than one purpose.
And so, um, which is really important for us.
Um, and I, and in that vein, something interesting happened.
So we, we, we have AI built into our systems
and we've now had a lot of pushback from teachers
who don't want to use the AI features at all.
And so it's really interesting, some
of our former rock stars
that were really pushing the envelope around, um, using, uh,
AI and trying it in their classroom have now really kind
of shrunk back and are pulling back on the use
and are showing a little bit more hesitation
and resistance to using AI in the classroom.
And really not sure how I feel about that yet.
I I think I've gotta see more, um, and hear more from them.
But it was a real curious thing to me
because they were so gung-ho, they were so fascinated by it,
and they were so excited about it at the beginning
of last year, but recently toward the end of this year,
they've been really pulling back away, um,
from AI in the classroom.
So I'm anybody else seeing that?
Or is it just the few that I'm noticing,
super curious.
Why
Have, has there been any kind of trend in the answers
or just kind of like themes emerging?
Um, they, they are hesitant to use any AI feature
around grading right now.
That seems to be the part
that they're hesitant, most hesitant about.
Um, and we had a, a strong push.
They still, uh, like the AI tutors,
but they are very,
they're becoming more selective on how they use those.
Um, but they are very hesitant with using AI
to assess student work.
And so I don't know if it is that they just need to, um,
have more, uh, experience with it or, or what,
but that's the, that's the theme
I'm, I'm noticing right now.
So I think it's worth digging into a little bit more
to figure out where their hesitation is coming from
and if it's something that, you know, we need
to collectively address
or if there really is something here that, um,
is worthy of discussion.
So we'll see. Nobody else is having that.
I think we have, we have kind of a gamut of folks where,
um, some people are pushing and pushing
and wanting to use more AI depending on what it is
that they're doing in their classrooms.
And then we have others that are extremely hesitant
and, um, are probably grateful
that we don't have a specific policy or something in place
because they don't want to, um, go down that path.
Um, and then we have an everybody else in between as well.
So I think that it's, um, I don't know, like
for me, in speaking with our deans of academics, um,
I think they're kind of going along with
what Ashley was saying earlier,
and they are wanting to scale back
on tech that we are using.
Um, and it's, it's in it,
it's gonna be interesting this year
because we, it sounds like some of you is,
are in the same boat as some of some of you where, um,
we are creating an AI
essentially like development team to talk about
where we wanna go and how we want to incorporate things.
Um, and that was just kinda sprung on me, I think yesterday.
So, um, so it, it will be interesting to see
we're, I think as a school we've kind of waited to see
how the waters were gonna calm down and
or if they were gonna calm down
and what was gonna happen in the end.
Um, and then we're just kind of pretty hesitant with
where we're going, um, with things.
So it doesn't really give a lot of answer to your question,
but it's kind of an explanation of how we're, um,
slowly moving along.
I like that you have a whole team dedicated to that.
Who would be on that team besides you, Scott?
Oh, is that a trick question? I
Don't know.
I don't know that yet.
Sorry. Very often it's a team of like me,
hello, I'm the team, you know, so
I, I know there's gonna be others.
I just don't know who it is yet.
Gotcha. I would be curious to see, you know,
if you're gonna pull teachers
or if parents come in, things of that nature.
It'd be interesting to see.
Um, one of the other pieces that's coming up a lot from our,
our parents is the, um, is conversations around, um,
the security in ai.
And so what are we doing as a, as an institution
to provide security when students are engaging with ai.
Um, and so we've had a, we've had a lot
of parents forming their own committees, um,
and coming together to try to, Cindy's eyes got huge.
I was like, I know it's a little scary
when they do that, isn't it?
And they banned together and they
have conversations without us.
Um, but they are having conversations around
what they think is appropriate.
And some of it's been great in terms of, you know, um,
they understand like they don't want their
middle schoolers to have phones.
They don't want their, uh, their, their littlest
to have smart watches in the classroom and,
and they wanna make sure that there's a certain amount
of time dedicated to play and to non-tech.
Uh, and so it's been interesting to see parents starting to,
to become more involved around this, uh,
even though they're not necessarily heavy users themselves,
um, of, of ai.
Uh, so it's, I'm curious, is anyone else, um,
and having parents come to you or,
or having parents band together
and have, create their own committees
or anything like that with you guys?
How's that working for you?
Uh, we work with some parent committees.
Um, some parent committees want us to present,
and by us it's usually like my team as well
as the library team, just
'cause we have been in the last few years really pushing
for our digital literacy curriculum,
so at least they're trying to evolve this.
But we definitely get a share of parents who are like,
I want no tech in school.
I'm like, that's just not realistic.
You know, that's not really helping the kids be prepared.
Um, and you know, we also have the issue of like,
there's still budget teachers with PTSD from the pandemic,
and so we do get pushback in those areas,
but I think if you just tie them all to kind
of the greater theme of digital literacy
and like, this is all related
to help kids just be more prepared in our online world
where, you know, there's just constant updates
and constant misinformation.
Like, I, I think that's kind
of the approach we've been taking
that's been getting a little bit of traction.
That's great. We, um, one of our,
our parent committees is called Tech Wise.
Um, I think it's a great name.
I wish we could have used it for something else,
but they have been very instrumental in
supporting us, which has been great.
Um, and uh, part of that is, um, they
as a group are now moving up in the, they were elementary
and now they're, those parents are
now moving into the middle school.
And so, um, what we have found is
because they are getting to have so much conversation
around this with us, they're actually more supportive
of the tech decisions that we're making.
Um, and so, uh, I think it's, there's been,
there's definitely a positive spin here.
Um, but they, uh, they do need more, um,
they need more support in terms of education, uh,
of the tools that we're using.
And so, um, I think that's something that we're gonna have
to, to focus on this year is supporting our parents
and their knowledge and understanding of how we use a,
how we use AI and then where it lives in our systems.
Because right now, you know, we could say, oh,
we use this tool for this particular purpose,
but the truth of the matter is the AI
lives in all of our systems.
Um, and so having, uh, parents and,
and even our faculty understand the extensive, uh, presence
of ai, um, I think is something that we don't,
we haven't done a good job of in the past.
Um, maybe even because we, ourselves as our teams are
so kind of isolated and siloed, we don't know just
how pervasive it is.
Um, but I think that as we are essentializing,
as we are trying to streamline our systems, uh,
it's incumbent upon us to kind of help our, our folks, all
of our folks understand just how much, um, we rely on it
and the ways in which we rely on it.
Um, 'cause it's in everything. Can we,
Can we talk about, uh, digital literacy for just a second?
So you guys kind of touched on that, but I'd love to stop
and dive in and hear what are you using
to help educate your students kind of in our current world
and when, and who does it?
'cause that's been an issue that has seemed
to evolve a little bit in the, the last couple of years
of like, who owns it?
Like, do you guys have, um,
like a early morning like advisory
period or something like that?
Like where does it live in the schedule?
And then what type
of curriculum are you using to address this?
We are approaching this from three different ways.
Um, we have a ninth grade student life program
that I am one of the teachers of.
And, um, I teach, um, I teach that in the fall, um,
maybe in the spring to be determined if they're gonna allow
that or not, but we'll see.
Um, and then we have an advisory program.
Um, the hope was that I would not be an advisor this year so
that I could travel to all of the different advisories
to have small group discussions.
Um, that has not, um, come to reality.
And so what I'm doing is creating short, um, modules
that are very detailed that a teacher could run
and have some discussions about with, um, an exit ticket
so I can see what the kids are, are getting from those.
And then we also have what we call programming days.
They're like teacher work days,
but the kids still have to come in
and, um, we're gonna be doing some programming on that.
And, and I'm using a variety of different tools
and resources to build this curriculum on my
own, essentially.
So
We do A pretty extensive program.
Um, it's computer skills starting at third grade
with my colleague Dove on the call.
Uh, and then in the fourth grade,
I see the kiddos once per semester, fifth grade,
twice per semester, so four times for the year.
Sixth grade, I see them once a week, the entire grade
for the full year.
And then we pause. And then in the ninth grade,
I have a six week cycle in the spring as an attend,
as an extension of their health class into digital health.
And I touch, basically the entire spring semester
is building up, um, literacy skills, starting
with algorithms and like data collection
and data science to machine learning
and how machines are trained
and whatnot, to, um, like playing
with like machine models to like,
like a teachable machine situation.
Uh, and then we fully vest into playing with AI
and then like digest it, uh,
and then move forward into online communication and whatnot.
Very cool.
Um, we take like a bit more, um,
we do have like standalone technology and library classes,
but we do, in our upper school, we do more, um,
based on advisory as well as assemblies.
And, uh, we do a really big, um,
dive into our RUP at the beginning of the year.
'cause that's kind of like the basis of our digital
literacy, uh, I guess standards.
Um, they tie with our school values.
Um, and then we, so
multiple teachers cover digital citizenship,
so it could be like the English teachers
or it could be your homeroom teachers in lower school,
or it could be the library teachers were myself.
Uh, we did like a really big spreadsheet a few years ago
that were like, okay, who owns which.
So, um, we're still, it's still a work in progress.
There's like a lot of gaps, especially with AI work.
So people are still kind of, you know,
taking ownership of different things.
Um, curriculum wise, we do follow common sense, you know,
um, disclaimer, I don't love their curriculum.
I don't know if any of you agree.
Uh, I have really enjoyed day of ai, um,
and I've actually adapted a lot of their curriculum to,
like our advisories as well as, um, like kind
of our older audiences.
Um, yeah, everything is still, still a work in progress.
I, I like Google's digital literacy curriculum as well.
Thank you. Yeah, we, um, we are trying, we,
we definitely have computer science courses
and of course we, we are trying to have that progression
of learning from, uh, from pre-K through 12,
but what we are trying to do is integrate the digital
learning, digital learning skills, um,
and attributes in all subjects
and in all grade levels, uh, which makes it more complex,
of course, when you're trying
to develop curriculum around that.
Um, but what we have d done is, you know,
we have borrowed the best, um, from, from the,
from the experts and we have, uh, taken
what is already there and sort of, um, added it
to our curriculum where,
where it makes the most sense for it to be added.
And it's still a progress
or a work in progress for us as well.
We are struggling with a few things of, you know,
who's gonna teach that specifically.
Um, how do we ensure that it's been taught,
I think is the hardest part of that.
Um, you know, it's one thing to have a math standard
and you know, you can't go on until
that math standard has been mastered.
And, uh, but with the digital literacy skills,
it's a little bit more soft and a little bit more vague.
And so we're trying to be very intentional about, um,
you know, this skill must be taught at this level so
that we can teach this skill.
Um, but ensuring that it is taught, um, is a,
is a more difficult piece of it.
And so, um, we're,
we're still struggling with that a little bit.
I think it helps if like your, um,
senior admin make it a priority.
It's like one of your, uh, like pillars
for the next five years, you know,
I would agree with that. I
think that one of the hardest parts of all of this,
all the conversations that we've had so far are who owns it
and, uh, who's on the team,
and then how do we make sure that it comes to fruition?
And, uh, so it's, it's one thing to have, uh, a great idea
or to have a plan, but, um, you know, who's at the table
and who's, who's participating.
And then, um, you know, where's that accountability
and follow up and follow through.
I think it's really difficult.
So it looks like we just have a couple minutes left.
Anybody else have questions
that they'd like to ask of the group
I have to head out, but I would love to get a recording
of this, especially if any of you talk about kind of
what your AI committees are doing.
Thank you all.
Thanks Mimi. Yeah, so let's dive into that.
So if you have an AI committee at your school,
what are they doing this upcoming year?
What's the plan?
I could answer that. We've, um, this is Connie.
We've had an AI committee, um,
since AI really became a big deal in, was it November
of 2022?
So we started that committee in February of, um, that year,
was it whatever it was.
And I guess this is our third or fourth year.
So initially we started developing policies of, of, um, fa
for faculty and students as far as, um,
that we would involve the safety.
We, we address different things and then that was modified.
Um, and then we've launched certain tools
that our committee has
provided training for teachers on that.
And we're currently working on identifying, um, faculty
and student competencies of things that we want them
to be able to do, whether that be, um, create a prompt
or for teachers, it would be productivity
or using the tools that we own, the AI tools
that we have subscriptions of.
So that's what we've been doing.
I did have a parent group that met with me in the fall, um,
that wanted, uh, to be, wanted us to
do more AI training in the school day.
Uh, especially for the older, for the younger,
we didn't allow teachers to use, um, AI in sixth grade
and below, except with one particular safety tool
that was a tutor, the Flint, and now the title.
So only things that have a walled garden,
that's the only thing we use.
So that's some of, of what we've been doing.
I did do lead parent, uh, workshops.
I've written articles and things,
so just, just sharing that.
I don't know. We're all trying and it keeps changing.
Connie, who was on your AI committee?
Like what was, what, what did
We, yeah, we had our tech specialists on the committee
from each school.
We, not the lower ones, but more of the middle, the upper,
and then teachers who had a passion.
So our physics teacher wanted to be on the committee.
It was a volunteer thing.
Um, some, you know,
the thing about committees, sometimes people leave.
I've, I've got to, at our admin retreat, recruit a couple
of teachers from each school to make sure that we have
teachers that, um, are interested
because it does take a lot of work and research.
But that's who was on our committee.
We didn't have parents, we didn't have students.
Although we talk to students,
I think we need to add students.
Um, so I think it, you know, we're all trying to, to change
and to migrate and to, um, things keep changing.
You know, we're talking about curriculum
and we had a very concrete curriculum
and then we had turnover, and then we tried pushing in,
and then we did classes again.
So I think we just have to be flexible, uh, to make sure
that we can ensure that the students have those skills.
One thing that I wanted to ask the group, you know,
in the state of Georgia, there's now a
mandatory computer science course.
How are independent schools responding to that?
Um, do we feel increased pressure?
You know, is that a question
that you guys are thinking about?
Anybody? Just wonder, do you feel pressure, Jen?
I I do. I feel pressure.
I feel pressure, um, to have a full,
like we only offer computer science skills, speci, you know,
in the traditional sense of what that means as a class
in our upper school, you'll see elements
of computer science taught in our middle
and lower, uh, in various classes,
but there's no, uh, you know, it's not like math
that runs all the way through or a different subject.
And so I, I wonder sometimes if we
don't dedicate enough resources there, um,
or if we're only looking at, um, at the classes
as electives, as optional types of courses instead of
as part of the core, as part of what it means to,
to be a well-rounded student.
So I'm with you there.
I I'm not sure that we have a, I don't know
that we feel pressure, but I feel as an educator,
there's some pressure to, you know, to have that.
Any other questions that anyone has?
Well, y'all, I think that that wraps us up.
I want to thank Jennifer for leading us today.
You have been a fantastic moderator.
I think I, I don't know about y'all,
but I've taken like a, a whole page of notes here of,
of things that I wanna follow up in some action items.
So great job everyone.
Um, Cindy, thank you for being here
and for Todd for sponsoring us.
We appreciate the support through this workshop.
I hope you guys all have a fantastic
start of the school year.
Um, one last thing before we go.
I did wanna let you know Atlas is in the works right now
with, um, offering some additional support
around this topic.
And so we are going to be, um,
releasing coming soon some courses around ai
and this is actually in partnership with Ed three Dow.
So a lot of, you know, re from over there.
So we actually have three courses
that we're gonna be rolling out.
One is Project-Based Learning and ai.
One is Design Thinking and ai,
and Last Critical Thinking, media Literacy and ai.
So, um, those are something to keep an eye out for as again,
you're looking for support, resources,
professional development for the upcoming school year.
They're gonna be asynchronous courses
that are just available, um, anytime,
but it's gonna be a cohort of like independent school
people going through those.
So, all right everyone, well hope you have a wonderful rest
of your day and we'll talk soon.
Everybody take care. Thanks for coming.