IT Meetup: Risk, Governance, and Planning Ahead
Presented by:
Eston Melton, Chief Information Officer at The Westminster Schools in Atlanta, opened this conversation about cyber risk with a hard question: if ransomware hit tonight, who would you call first, and do they know it? Technology leaders from one-person shops to larger teams compared notes. The group traded experiences with phishing tests, from first attempts to monthly simulations run for years, and Eston shared the idea of treating them like fire drills rather than gotcha moments. Attendees who had lived through incidents discussed working with cyber insurers and being candid with them. One described an AI-generated voice call requesting a payroll change, which led their school to require face-to-face approval. The group closed with plans for the year ahead: checking vendors’ security, protecting backups, handling personal phones, and preparing for an internet outage. Anyone wondering how their incident plan would hold up will find practical ideas from peers here.
Transcript
Okay, everyone. Welcome to another meetup.
Today, we are going to be talking about IT.
We're going to be talking about risk, governance, and planning ahead.
So, big strategy at this one, big ideas, but also hopefully some
practical takeaways and some good ideas and sharing in all of these.
So, we encourage you to bring your problems.
If you have a particular question that you came to the group with today, we'll
definitely make time for those. And if you have, again, great ideas to share, we
encourage that as well. So,
we have a special guest facilitator today.
So, from the Atlanta region, we have Eston Melton.
He is the chief information officer at Westminster. So welcome so much.
Thank you for facilitating for us today.
Happy to. Good afternoon, if you happen to be on that half of the country today.
Late good morning. Happy lunch, everyone, to everyone else who's elsewhere.
Absolutely. And if you want to kick it off and go ahead and warm them up with some
questions, I think they're ready to go.
Sure, happy to. So, I'm relatively new to the Atlas world, really to the
independent schools space in general.
I'm in my, I think, 109th day as the CIO at Westminster, but no one in particular
is counting. But I spent the last decade as the CIO for a school district here in
the metro Atlanta region, where governance carries its own different type of
weight. Just one bit of, I mean, normally in housekeeping, because we're going to
talk, I think, quite a bit about cybersecurity and potentially get vulnerable with
one another. I'm scrolling through the participants list here, and
PP Zoom admin, thank you, whomever that is.
If we could all just stipulate that whatever personal AI assistants and recorders
and whatnot we might otherwise have at our disposal, I think it might be a more
conducive space if we could all just agree that we'll keep those out of the
environments, and perhaps we can just all peer check one another on that.
And given the volume of folks who had expressed interest, nearly 100 folks, a good
chunk of whom, a third have already shown up, we can use the chat space
vigorously to flag folks down along with all the hand waving that Zoom will
do.
I think it's been a pretty busy week for all of us in IT, even going back to late
last week as we watched the, let's see,
Microsoft had its outage and probably bit any number of folks.
And then we watched the FAA go down as they tried to do a copper
to fiber transition, which we've all probably led at some point in our lives.
My team is watching the Apple status board as Apple Music and some of its
infrastructure is zonking out, and the feds,
close to home for me, Fort Meade, is having some issues with its classified network
system. So, IT experts
are having a busy day. So,
but many of those just kind of infrastructural, as far as we know, none of them
necessarily related to, I don't know, firing actual programmers and replacing them
with AI. But let's talk about the hard stuff.
Let's talk about cybersecurity and readiness.
I'm curious if anyone wants to be vulnerable in the opening salvo for
today. If a ransomware or account compromise were to hit your institution
or your entity tonight, or it's the first thing you walk into tomorrow morning,
who makes the critical decisions about what to do next
on and outside your technology team?
And do those people know now at this moment
that they are your first three phone calls or knocks on the door?
Can I ask a quick question before we get into that?
And that is, is your role as a CISO the only hat that you wear in your school?
Well, you just called me a CISO.
Well, job title-
But my job title is chief information officer.
So, as I told a room full of elementary students this morning, I'm the chief
information officer, I'm the chief technology officer, I'm the chief information
security officer, I'm the chief privacy officer.
So, I am graced with a team. I recognize too that my
institution is distinct at one end of a long tail, and I'm particularly interested
in advancing today those of our colleagues who are one-person shops, because I
think, or small shops, because I realize that my long
tailness is not representative of our community.
So, the thing that sometimes keeps us up at night happens to one of us in the
morning. Who are our first calls? Who do we hit up?
And I will invite you to come off of mute.
I think we're a small enough, large classroom size, we can popcorn out.
Okay, I can jump in
if you can guys hear me.
We can hear you.
Yeah. Small shop, only two people.
And we've been working together for over 12 years, so obviously if anything
happens, it's just immediately call to my colleague here at the office.
But to be honest, in my head, what really worries me is not our reaction,
but how our business office, our accountants and stuff like this, how they are
reacting to crises.
And taking this as a safe place, I'm taking this from my own
experience where we had a phishing attack with overtaken account, which
business office inform us with five days delay.
And that's really, really serious break of any protocols from my perspective.
So, I'm kind of flipping there what you were asking for, but I think it's
equally important in our job that other
sites equally understands the need for quick communication, quick action,
and not waiting.
So, you're taking it a step further to the importance of broader communication?
Okay.
Correct. Yes, definitely.
So, one of your first, you named both the business office and the-
Yeah.
Yes.
So, yes. Business office comm, my chief operation officer, which is also
CFO.
Mm-hmm.
And obviously right after notification to kind of the school.
And then document everything, every step.
Whatever you do, put it on a paper, so later on when you write a report to
authorities and to insurance company.
Mm-hmm.
Then you have everything in place.
You're already jumping into
implementing your response plan.
Who else is on the
short-term phone call besides business office and comms team, and if you're lucky
enough, a colleague or two?
I'm a one-person shop at a very small school.
I always think that there is some trade-off to, yes, I'd love to have more people
on my team to get involved, but really small schools can be pretty nimble as far as
responding to these types of attacks and isolating and smaller teams to
inform, and compliance is often easier if you do need to pull the plug on certain
things.
For us, the top of our response plan is
a call to the executive director of the school, but also to our MSD.
We're supported by a local managed service provider, so they're at the top of that
list also to enlist that additional manpower that we get from them.
Very cool. All right.
I can chime in here. I'm a medium-sized school, three people.
Two people report directly to me, and there's myself, the director.
Our biggest or most recent issue would be, I've been pretty lucky nothing's
happened to any of our school systems in regards to accounts being phished, but
there have been a few of our faculty who have gotten phished with their personal
accounts. And they're looking at us because they feel that if the initial phishing
came through our Google domain, that what is our response to that when, in
most cases, they clicked on something to start the whole thing.
And so in that point, I'm kind of like, "Well, what should we do?" Because our
systems weren't attacked.
So I guess I'm looking for some suggestions from other people.
Have other people experienced that, and what would their response be in those
situations?
I would normally tell my people, sorry,
that I'm sorry that happened to them.
You need to be careful what you click, but we can help you rectify the damage that
was done, reset your passwords, and check for damage.
Yeah. And we do that. We talk to them about that.
But it becomes more and more, then how far does it go down?
There have been some students who asked this question, but they weren't looking at
it because, "Oh, my GFS account was, or school account's been attacked." It was
really with their personal account, and they were attacked personally through
everything that way. But because they're using their computer, they're asking us,
"Well, what should else should we do?" And we go through this, we say, "Change the
passwords, check the account. Do your due diligence.
Check with your parents to see if all your banking information is okay." But is
that sufficient enough in this time?
Is there something else I may be missing or something we should be doing at that
level to, I guess, assist, other than additional training?
Because as you get more people, new people in, you may need to refresh that
training. If it's not going to be yearly, then maybe you should make it yearly
training for everyone to kind of let them get up to speed on the new phishing
tactics that are out there.
Just looking for thoughts there.
One consideration might be that the habit and the knowledge that allowed someone to
click through and be a victim
with their personal account is the same skills and knowledge that may very well
have allowed them to be a victim logged into their work-related account.
Absolutely.
And so, whatever training associated with their Gmail or their Hotmail is directly
relevant to what happens with their work one, right?
Yeah.
And I would also consider what you described
sounds like a plausible entry point for a compelling tabletop exercise.
What begins, what initiates as an employee who is made vulnerable logged
into a personal account? Because I will tell you one of the things that has been
eye-opening for me is I've noticed that
in my institution, for many of our employees, their work-assigned machine is their
only machine.
Mm-hmm.
Right? And so,
if anything's going to go wrong, not to jinx anything, and certainly equipment and
systems and whatnot can be undermined, but human behavior is always our weakest
point in the chain.
Start with what's real, and what is real is people on their work machine but using
their personal resources can be undermined and taken advantage of.
Take that a step further, because you can put a real name and story behind that
training. And you might even then,
if there's a silver lining to it, that person then is positioned to be an
evangelist for healthy hygiene when it comes to recognizing signs of phishing,
because it could have been much worse.
Maybe sometimes it has been, the person who did go buy the gift card.
Turn that person into an advocate for doing things right and recognizing those
warning signs early.
Yeah.
How many of us have done a tabletop exercise
with someone, and realizing, some of us are teams of one.
How many of us have done a tabletop exercise, whether with a partner, whether with
the one other person in our team, a colleague who's another employee, maybe someone
in the business office or the insurance company?
How many of us have done a tabletop exercise around a cyber incident within the
last six months? And let's pick a compelling Zoom emoji
reaction. Let's do a heart. If you've done it within the last six months, throw a
heart out there.
One, Michael.
Ian, you popping out there.
All right.
Eston, if I may interject here, you all, if you have not done one and you need a
little bit of handholding, I dropped a link in the chat.
There is a fantastic cybersecurity tabletop simulation that is guided
by AI. So the AI kind of plays like game show host, and what you can do is bring
your senior admin team together in a meeting, and it basically walks you through
all the different prompts and the injections, and it holds your hand.
It's a little bit multiple choice.
And so that way, they can have the experience of getting through some of those
conversations, but it also gives a little bit of pushback of like, "Okay, you did
this, but surprise, this happened the next day." So it throws in some different
twists. So check that out. It's a good one.
Yeah.
Thank you.
Ian and Artur, I want to put you back on the spot since you already were brave
enough to come up off mute. As one and two-person shops,
what does it look like for you to feel and be ready
for whatever might come knocking at your door and surprise you when you come into
work tomorrow?
That's an interesting question.
Yeah. I
would say I have felt more ready in the two years that we've been partnered with
our MSP than I did before, just because it was pretty isolating to be a
one-person team without that kind of knowledge base to access.
Go ahead, Artur.
Yeah, I definitely think it would...
I've been here for a long time, so I don't know how it would feel to be on the
other side.
I'm going to give a little credit to Atlas here.
I've been a member for a couple years, and I participate in a lot of those
security webinars and stuff like this.
And
I think big eye-opener for me about two years ago was, I took that long security
training, like five months, I think it was,
which was...
I don't remember the company which we did.
Nine-
Yes, I'll link it in the chat if they want to learn about it.
Yeah.
Great training, gentlemen. Kind of scary, kind of eyes-opening.
Lots of great materials. And I made sure that, we're a tiny shop
and we have a limited budget, but I made sure that both me and my colleague, we
both attended it.
We didn't miss a single section. And
I would say we probably managed to implement maybe 50% what we learned,
but that's already huge improvement to what we had.
So my recommendation to little shops would be, just work on your personal
knowledge. Train, train, train. Watch those webinars. Keep your eyes open.
And if I can add, two weeks ago, I did a phishing test on my population.
I sent a fake phishing email to all my faculty and staff.
And I'm going to present tomorrow on a staff meeting results, because from my
perspective, we failed. 14% of my faculty and staff clicked on a link to change
the password, which they very well know that I would never send an email like that.
So even with a small shop, you can do those little steps.
Train yourself, be proactive with testing your users and trying to
open their eyes and making them more sensitive to what they're clicking, what
they're seeing, and stuff like this.
Actually, I must say, I got multiple people asking me, "Is this a phishing attack?"
And I would make them funny emails saying, "Yes, I was playing, trying to catch you
guys." And they were very proud people and very embarrassed, but they were stopping
me on the hallway. And that definitely started the conversation.
And I'm planning to continue it tomorrow during the meeting when I'm going to talk
with them that I'm going to do more of those tests.
And I want us to be at the level about 4% or better.
For education, it's about 4% benchmark, where it should be.
Because it's not only protecting us as a school, but also protecting their private
accounts, so they are going to learn with us.
Are you using a product off the shelf to deliver those phishing?
I use the
testing account from
KnowBe4.
KnowBe4. Yeah.
Yeah.
The education benchmark of 4% sounds very familiar.
That's what I used in Decatur for a few years.
Yeah.
Anyone else have... So it sounds like you're maybe new to a phishing campaign
regimen. Anyone having done a phishing campaign regimen for several years?
Anyone have a mature regimen? Because that is a very common vector for getting the
human weakness in the chain to get into a school entity.
Anyone happy with their phishing campaign training intervention?
Hi, all. I'm happy to share. My name's Brad. I work at the Langley School.
We've been using KnowBe4 for about four or five years now, and we've had a phishing
campaign where it sends a simulated phishing attack email once a month to
every user. And we have slowly seen our numbers come down.
And with KnowBe4, you can customize it to, I think there's like five different
categories of really blatantly easy to recognize versus really challenging
to navigate through. And you can kind of choose what kind of templates you want to
send out, and you can make them completely random.
Now we're about, for all of our faculty and staff, I think we're hovering around
maybe one or two clicks per month, which is pretty good.
But as we all know, it only takes one.
And to answer your question, I sent a little bit earlier about what do you do to
feel confident and prepared?
As schools and any other industries, we can have the latest and greatest
cybersecurity tools in place and still somehow you can still get
phished or you can still get attacked. It only just takes one.
So what I've learned is the best thing that we should be confident and comfortable
is, is establishing a really good relationship with your cybersecurity provider,
your insurance provider, and if you have a broker, making sure that you have a plan
in place with them, because you might know how to fix everything independently, but
they're going to advise you not to. They're going to advise you, "Okay, hey, stop.
We're going to get some counseling.
We're going to tell you exactly what to do step by step." So the first step I've
learned is just to report it immediately to your cybersecurity insurance provider
and/or broker, and then they will give you next steps to do.
Because something you think might be helpful, they might advise you not to do in
that situation. And so, that's just the best thing that I've learned.
It's almost not a matter of if, it's going to be probably when.
Even if you have the best tools and the latest, greatest trainings and all that,
people still find a way to hack you. So that's the best advice I've gotten.
So I try to invest a little bit more time with maintaining a strong partnership
with those individuals and those companies so that I feel prepared to know what to
do and who to reach out to if that time comes.
Brad, you're teaching at the Langley School.
You are right down the road from George C. Marshall High School, right?
Started-
Oh, yeah. Very nice.
So, yeah.
Very nice, yep.
I want to ask you about you, because you've been doing KnowBe4 for four or five
years now. So that 1.5%, 1.5%, maybe
phishing-prone rate, or 1 to 1.5 clicks a month, you said.
What do you do with that data? Do you see it's the same staff over time?
Is it new faculty? Are they in high vulnerability groups, like in the finance
office or your safety team? Like, what do you do when you see a ping on the
console?
So, for the most part, it is repeat users.
Mm-hmm.
And every time they click on a phishing link, they enroll in a follow-up training
automatically.
For some users, I feel like they're just not getting it.
They're probably going to fall for it time and time again, and you just have to
know your school is only as strong as your weakest link.
However, they're not in really high-profile roles, so the likelihood of them
actually receiving a targeted spear phishing attempt is very unlikely, but they
are still a vulnerability. And following up with them on helping them to understand
why it was a phishing simulation, what specific things to look out for, it's
helpful, but it's not going to make you
100% defendable.
Cool. Yeah, just curious. I remember a few years ago, Google has
one of the best job titles I've ever seen is like a chaos maven or chaos
coordinator or something like that.
It's just the person who's responsible for managing their phishing campaigns or so
on. And one of the things that they shared in that blog post, I'll try to find it
and maybe ask Ashley to disseminate it to the folks who registered today, is they
treat phishing campaigns the way that schools treat fire drills, in that they are
announced ahead of time. And I think our chart, like, if you're getting new
into phishing campaigns or it's new behaviors for folks, I think about how we
onboard staff, how an organization matures into its muscle memory of how
to respond to a suspicious message,
versus what is this, what do I do in the moment, and how to strike that balance was
new. Because I remember when we were new to KnowBe4, my team started
using that tool as a gotcha, and that was not
very healthy. And in fact, Brad, speaking of Fairfax County, I remember reading the
headlines. Fairfax County, right during Teacher Appreciation Week,
used KnowBe4 as part of the campaign to send staff a message saying, "Here is
your Teacher Appreciation Week gift card," which
got a lot of attention- ... but made teachers feel awful.
And so, there is the gotcha component and teach folks a lesson, but how much is it
worth chewing up the goodwill amongst your constituents? Anyway, yeah, phishing.
It's funny you mention announcements, because that's exactly what I was thinking
about going in direction. We are actually redesigning our approach to security
overall, and I was thinking about making those phishing campaigns as
virtually. This is the part of our security approach at school, just like the fire
drill or shelter in place, which we did today.
Yeah. I think, hold up, I might have... I found it. I'll put it in the chat.
It's from a couple years ago,
if it's sparked your interest.
A few folks invoked
not only the criticality of your MSP, but also the role of insurance coverage.
Does anyone want to be brave and come off mute and say,
is there a question you really, really hope your insurance provider doesn't ask
you?
Hello, everyone. I'm Raymond.
Hey, Raymond.
I'm from the New Community School.
I'm going to say to that question is, don't be afraid to be honest with your
insurance provider about your risk and vulnerabilities, because it's better to be
truthful and honest and let them know versus not.
And then when you go through a cyber incident, which is
what we had to do, it doesn't look good
when they have
a company or set of companies that come and actually test out your knowledge and
your networks. And if you haven't been forthright and they find out, it doesn't
look good. So don't be afraid to actually be open and be honest when you fill out
your information on
your vulnerabilities. If you can't check everything off the list, explain why, and
just be forthright with that information. It's best that way.
I appreciate that. I apologize if in my attempt to ask a question flippantly or
humorously, I came across as suggesting withhold or be incomplete in how
you answer a questionnaire or an inventory from your insurance provider.
I didn't mean to suggest that at all.
So thank you for checking that and giving me the chance to clear the air on that,
Raymond. Good call. I appreciate that.
Oh, yeah. Not a problem.
Particularly because I'm sure we've all noticed the insurance premiums and even
just policies in general have been increasingly difficult to wrestle around.
Has anyone here had to go, in fact, like whole cycle?
Does anyone have something that has happened to them recently who wants to discuss
what it was like to have to engage with a provider in general, lessons learned from
having to partner with that third-party entity and go through the recovery and work
with the insurance coverage entity to get back on your feet?
We went through one- I
can't- Oh, sorry.
Go ahead.
We went through one last year, and we provided them so much information, and
basically they just spit it back out at us and told us that that was their
investigation and they were done.
And
nothing they provided us was something we didn't provide them.
So it was kind of frustrating. I was hoping for more in-depth
information and vulnerabilities and discovery.
Yeah.
Yeah.
That sounds really frustrating, Kim. I'm sorry that you had to contend with that.
Yeah. I definitely think it depends on who you have.
My experience,
we did provide them with a lot of information, but they did help us with some other
findings and SOC gaps.
One thing I would say is that communication kind of fell off towards the end part
for us. Ours happened very recently, back in September, and we're still going
through file forensics. As of about two weeks ago, just final,
we had our triage meeting and we had our final meeting and just some other things.
And our company is not US-based, so different time zones.
So our company is CFC Limited, and they're United Kingdom-based.
So that was kind of a thing to work through as far as communication and scheduling
meetings, is we had to figure out times that worked based on my Eastern Standard
Time zone and their United Kingdom time zone, so.
Rayon, it sounds like you're in the middle of something going on now. Are you okay?
No, I'm actually good. That was the bell ringing, so if y'all heard that in the
background. So, it's extra help in my school right now, so. But yeah, we're okay.
I'm very thankful for the systems we had in place.
We got a ransomware attempt on our school on September 14th, and
after doing forensics, and it's just, I'm a one-man shop, so I can relate to those
on here that are just one man only. So with myself and our local
MSP, we had to do a lot of digging once we became aware and
alerted that someone was on our systems, and they tried to take over
our networks and our servers. Fortunately, they didn't. Nothing ever went down.
They just compromised a few files.
They weren't able to fully encrypt everything, and then our encryption software
applications that we had protected our main servers.
So that's really what saved us. But we did our due diligence, reported it.
I'll say about a month and a half, we are cleared.
But some other neighboring schools got hit up in this massive attack that was
taking place against Fortinet firewalls.
So,
but yeah, I can definitely... I don't want to take up the time for the whole entire
meeting or chat, but if anyone ever needs to talk about step-by-step what we
did
and what happened, I definitely don't mind sharing that information.
So we were very fortunate, but some of our neighboring
private schools and some of our public schools where we have relationships with,
they have been
locked down, and they've had to start over or they had to pay ransom.
We didn't have to, so we're very fortunate
to have survived.
Well, so it sounds like you... Is what happened to you, did it end up being
instruction halting?
What was that? I'm sorry.
Was it instruction halting, what happened at your particular school?
So at our particular school, nothing ever went down, so we never lost connectivity
or anything. So,
our teachers and students, they didn't know that ransomware even
occurred, because nothing got shut down.
Nothing was anomalous and nothing popped up on their screens or anything like that.
Congratulations. There are a lot of institutions, including entities with IT teams
a thousand times bigger than yours, that cannot say that.
So, way to
go- Right
... the one-man shop. That's awesome.
Right.
Yeah, good job.
I see too, so
Kim, on the other hand, wow, y'all.
So,
50K, that's a hard loss over there, so my heart goes out to you too.
And unfortunately, the reality is,
despite tremendous expertise and effort on our parts and the parts of our vendors
too, just our entire industry is asynchronous warfare.
And sometimes things go down, and our students, our infrastructure, and our time
pay the price. It's unfortunate. Are you and your kids whole yet?
It sounds like you had a frustrating experience working with your insurance
provider. Is your school back up and running? Are you intact?
Oh, us?
Yeah.
Oh, yeah.
Okay.
I mean, what happened was they hacked our CFO's email and then changed
a chain, email addresses in a chain to take out the original person who was
going to get paid something and put theirs in.
And then they set up a new bank account and asked for ACH payment, and the CFO did
it.
Oh, wow. Ah, okay.
Yep. Welcome to the club. That was exactly our attack.
Okay.
To the letter.
Yep.
Okay.
Two payments.
Well, yeah.
Two payments. Ouch.
Two payments total, and we actually went to our database and our first move
was we erase all ACH info from our database.
Because we knew that at least in that matter, we'll protect, we'll
know somebody, there's a number appears, there will be novelty.
And we were in the middle of changing financial accounting system, by the way.
So that was also weak point at the moment.
We've gone halfway through this meetup without invoking
AI, which I feel great about. It's nice not to talk about it for a moment.
I'll invoke it briefly to say there was a security blog or news update I saw this
week or earlier this about, we're in the age now where these attacks are
increasingly automated, and what used to take hours and hours or days are now much
more truncated as AI agents will string together vulnerabilities and gain access
to systems much more rapidly than in times past.
I am curious,
what strategies or tactics at this point have you all begun to
deploy when it comes to, for example, as you bring new MSPs online?
Like Ian, I think you said you're just in your second year having an MSP as part of
your toolkit.
How have you gone out to your partners who are like your second staff member, who
have your back to talk about how they're helping to mitigate against these types of
threats? Or just more broadly, compared to a year ago or two years ago, are there
new things you're talking to vendors about that you weren't asking about that
you're now holding them accountable to help keep your schools whole and intact?
I think we've seen,
we had a payroll change occur, attack
at the end of last school year via phishing.
So it was a simulated voice call asking for a payroll account
change.
It's one of those where you hear it back and you're like, "How did the person think
that was actually her?" But when it was a relatively new employee,
the phish
voice explained that they were on a cell phone, it was a bad connection, so they
kind of pre-explained why it might sound differently.
And it resulted in a little bit less of a technical change in how we do
things, and instead leveraging our small schoolness and that we were able to
enforce more face-to-face contact for those type of transactions, not allowing them
to occur over the phone or even electronically via email.
But that was something where
our MSP only has a couple schools. They also do
local enterprise and commerce organizations.
So we kind of had to educate them on how it works at schools, and now they've been
able to kind of help us rewrite some of those plans, so.
Cool.
I like Kim's add here in the chat about asking to see the vendor's own cyber
insurance policy and their written incident plans.
Again, if we're having difficulty getting cyber insurance, it's good to know that
these vendors have their own coverage in case something goes sideways.
And you just invoked, I think, an AI-generated voice attack, and
there's some comments in the chat too about that.
Anyone else have the school president's or executive director's voice or
someone else in the C-suite's voice emulated in a
AI-generated phone call or voicemail to a colleague in some
type of attack?
Thankfully, no, but there's a couple big cases around DC and Baltimore area with
deepfakes, so we're quite aware of it and trying to potentially
go away from
asking people to record their voices in a voicemail in order to not provide
footprints.
We don't know for sure, but we believe that the employee that was impersonated on
our call on the AI-generated phishing was,
she had a number of recorded professional development and parent
informational sessions that were publicly available, and we believe that they got
enough voice samples because there was probably over an hour of voice between those
sessions, that that's where they picked up enough stuff to train the AI on her
voice.
We amended the suspicious message response
script for our faculty this year. It had included the line, "When you get
the funny message, get verification,"
and made it explicitly face-to-face verification.
It had previously said, "Call someone." It's like, no,
go get face-to-face,
just to eliminate for any number of reasons.
If someone's talking to you funny over the phone, let's remove over-the-phone
funniness with a verification change also. Yeah.
What else are you holding your vendors and outside partners to accountability for
beyond their own cyber incident plans?
Any new things that you're leaning on them for outside support?
For critical vendors, we're requiring a SOC 2 audit.
Yeah.
So for the highly sensitive vendors, we're also monitoring them with BitSight,
which is a vendor risk management platform.
So I'm familiar with BitSight, which is very cool.
Say more about what BitSight is doing for you and how you're leveraging that,
because they've got a ton that they do. How are you using BitSight?
So we're just using it for basic monitoring.
We have about 60 criteria that we look at when we select a product, mostly pricing
and/or data security and privacy.
So we can enter our own custom questionnaires in, they follow up with the vendors,
make sure the questions get answered, and they can collect SOC audits for us, that
kind of stuff. They also alert us to any incidents involving those vendors that are
published. So, helpful. It's all of the confidential and sensitive PII
vendors for us that we're monitoring, which is only 25 in our case.
Yeah. I found them really helpful.
So rather than kind of relying on, "Oh, does this obscure ed tech vendor's
data breach warrants a headline somewhere?" I can go add them to a monitoring
tool and they'll clue me in.
Among other things, it was one of the really helpful things that BitSight was doing
for us. Very cool.
Yeah.
I would add, if you're looking at cyber insurance, the hard part is getting them to
add you as an additionally insured.
Right.
Because they'll cover you in the incident, and you really have to have leverage to
make that happen.
Right.
And in some cases, sometimes they'll offer you, they'll let you use a company
as long as they partner with them. So for us, Solis Security was a company that
they allowed us to use and take advantage of their services for free.
Of course, it's on a limited timeframe, but to continually monitor our accounts,
and then afterwards, the time ends, they'll give us a monthly price
that we'll have to pay monthly if we want to continue monitoring services.
But just leveraging another outside company.
And one other company that wasn't provided by our cyber insurance provider, but
just me having a connection with allowed me to take advantage and use their
services for a while during our incident was Flare.io. So I recommend that.
It is very expensive. It's a yearly charge, but it's great to
look at your risk exposure from the public.
You can just put in your domain for your school,
or whatever entity you want to look up, and it'll give you a breakdown of
all types of exposures based on your domain.
And you can tweak it however you want to.
But that was a very resourceful tool
that I used to see what other breaches, even before I'd been working at this
school, to see where some accounts had been compromised and things like that.
So I recommend Flare.io.
So, we've named quite a few websites and tools, heard some stories of
folks like Raymond and Kim who have gone through some incidents, some folks who
are very happy with mature campaigns and tools.
In the balance of 15 minutes or so, I'm just kind of curious, we are only at this
point a quarter, like a third of the way through the school year.
There's still plenty of work and runway ahead of us.
What are our aspirations for the balance of the school year?
What are we hoping to get done with the time we have remaining?
What are we planning to take to our leadership, to the board, as we're
never not in budget season, but what are we hoping to ask for?
Those of us who've been through something, we have the recency of an incident to
maybe motivate resource allocation. How are you leveraging that?
But really would like to invite folks to come off and chime in, like, what are you
hopeful for? What are you trying to turn into an opportunity?
What are you aspiring for with the balance of the school year, most of which is
still ahead of us?
I can chime in. In terms of new platforms, we're looking at Florida Mail
Workspace, which is one of several of that type, but
something to add on top of. We're a Google Workspace school, and
there's some functionality there in terms of identifying problematic messages,
inbound and outbound, filtering those out, quarantining, and there's this market
for additional layers. Florida Mail has some humans involved in
between to assist with identifying patterns and helping us vet
messages. So, that's a product we're looking at.
I'll tell you the product I'm excited about.
We're piloting CrowdStrike Identity Protection.
And
assuming it does what we need, it not only would prevent attackers from being able
to log in as users, it would prevent users from logging in from personal devices.
So that one, we're big CrowdStrike customers, Falcon Complete and SOC, SOC SIM.
So,
this could really tie into our overall security strategy.
And then looking ahead to next year, again with CrowdStrike, CrowdStrike Guardian
would give visibility into all AI usage from our users.
So even if they're doing shadow AI, we'd be able to detect it through their agent,
and we know they would be using their agent because they can't log into our tools
unless they're on our platform. So, kind of the combination of tools there is
really compelling. And then if I can put on the tinfoil hat for a little while,
Anthropic did just last month mention that they believe that AI is going to be
small enough to be able to infiltrate televisions and refrigerators and other home
appliances. So, we're doing a tabletop in three weeks
on what if there's no internet? And so, a lot of our solutions are SaaS, so we're
looking to harden procedures for downtime.
Do I expect the whole internet to be down for a month? No.
But,
we don't know which vendor's going to be attacked. We don't know if it'll be us.
So we've designed our network to be able to segment off pieces of IoT and just
elect door locks and building controls and that kind of stuff to stay online, but
kick off the light bulbs and the televisions and the Pelotons.
So, we're trying to get through that whole, what happens when AI
swarms start attacking? So that's kind of where we're focused.
Very cool.
What else have y'all excited and thinking aspirationally?
So, I can chime in on this one. With our end of
life of vSphere 8 coming next year, we are still not on immutable backup,
so we're taking advantage of that this year and doing a big overhaul of all of that
on that side of the equation to hopefully,
yeah, get us all up to date on all of that.
Are you thinking of sticking within the kind of VMware vSphere space, or are you
looking at moving? Because a lot of folks jumped out after the Broadcom
acquisition. Are you looking beyond that particular family?
We are looking at beyond. We haven't really decided on anything yet, but
we'd rather do that this academic year than wait until summer and try to do
something, so.
Cool.
Michael put a question up there. Michael, come off mute and ask your question.
Smartest person in the room.
This has been something we've been working on, mainly mobile devices.
Just wondering what your plan, Scott, is for handling devices.
Obviously, we try and push everyone, we're a Google school, so just use the Gmail
apps.
But it is very easy for someone to log into Veracross or other platforms on their
mobile device or personal device, so just curious how you're handling mobile.
It's the exception to the rule right now, unfortunately.
We're not providing the devices, therefore we can't manage the devices directly.
Plan is mobile application management to where if you don't have the app in our
container, you can't log in, but that is more, I said plan, it's wish at the
moment. I would not call it the plan.
That is a definite FY28 project for us, whereas Guardian, Protect Your Guardian for
AI detection is a wish. I think we'll get both.
But you're right, that is an area where we've had to make an exception.
It makes me a little queasy. I do think that phones are much safer devices
generally than laptops, so even just getting rid of the Windows and Mac laptops
feels like a huge win. But you're right, that is a gap.
Appreciate it.
Yeah.
I'm curious, have any of you undertaken to pursue NIST or CIS controls, adopt an
official formal cybersecurity framework?
No. I'll just speak for myself, no.
I mean, the idea of having such a formal security program at a school is...
I wish we could get there, but I just don't imagine it will happen.
I did it in Decatur, which is not a very...
It was
large by any kind of school standards, 5,500 kids,
but four times bigger than the school I'm at now.
It was a
worthy undertaking in that the pursuit helped us.
It gave us a framework to uncover the areas where we had not adopted policy and
procedure. It helped to really shine a light.
It was
not the destination, it was the journey, blah, blah, blah. English teacher.
Got it.
It was cool. And I don't think it's for now, but thinking aspirationally, maybe not
a this year kind of thing, but I think there's probably a different flavor that
might be a better fit for the environment I'm at.
But it's been tickling my mind as I continue as a new leader here to kind of kick
over logs and see kind of what's what, to answer my own question.
That is what is on my mind over here
in Atlanta.
There's also an adaptation specifically for independent schools, because you're
right, the scale and the scope is very different.
Yep.
Yes. And so, we've put together cybersecurity recommendations specifically for
these indie schools, and they're broken up into tiers.
So no matter where you are on this continuum, there's always work that we can be
doing. But I'm with you, the NIST framework and the other things, absolutely
incredible. Great resources as well.
Mm-hmm. Yeah. Well, we're winding
down on time. I just want to give space, are there any last-minute questions that
you all came on your minds that did not get evinced over the last
52 minutes? Are there some takeaways that you all have that would be helpful to
kind of put out there?
Wonderings, again, the smartest people in the room is the room, before
we break?
And I will also add on, you are officially off record.
I am stopping the recording, so.